(photo: Justice takes a breather. Statue outside the Federal Courthouse in NYC.)
December 20 Civil case conference with Judge Daniels
Note: audio recordings are not permitted in the court house, so I am relying on my own handwritten notes. I am not a lawyer and may have misunderstood some statements made during the conference. Corrections to these notes by any persons who attended this conference are welcome. Send comments to traderelvis@gmail.com
Cassidy Status:
Kevin Cassidy was scheduled to be sentenced on December 15th. Cassidy's lawyer Lawrence Gelber told the court that sentencing will now be on January 31st. Gelber said that the new date was set by the government and was not at the request of Cassidy.
The expectation is that there will be a 30 to 60 day window between when Cassidy is sentenced and when he goes to jail. During this time Cassidy will be deposed (asked questions under oath) and allowed to speak, for the first time, about the business rules that existed between Optionable and the Bank of Montreal defining how pricing information was to be shared between Optionable and BMO's back office. Judge Daniels expressed his personal doubt that Cassidy would have anything game-changing to say but supported the process by which Cassidy would be sentenced first and deposed later.
[Personal note: I have always doubted BMO's version of events as presented to BMO's Shareholders and Industry Analysts at their 2007 press conference and have been waiting for four years to hear Cassidy's version of events. Unlike Judge Daniels I'm thinking that Cassidy's deposition will reveal a credible alternate interpretation of the admitted actions taken by Lee, Cassidy and BMO's back office that will poke holes in BMO's publicized interpretation that scapegoated Cassidy to mask their own massive losses on excessive risky investments.]
First Up: CFTC
Eugene Smith of the CFTC reported that the CFTC recently finalized a Consent Order with Optionable and O’Connor and that the CFTC expects to reach a similar outcome with Cassidy. Lawrence Gelber said that he needs to wait until after Cassidy is sentenced, before having further discussions with either the CFTC or the SEC. No one from the SEC attended the conference. Marni Rae Robin stated that O’Connor has not settled with the SEC.
Next Up: CMEG / NYMEX
Daniel Pollack said that CMEG filed a motion for Summary Judgment and anticipates an answer from Nordlicht and Cassidy by January 18th. Pollack's position is that when Nordlicht, Cassidy and O'Connor sold NYMEX a 19% stake in Optionable, a warantee was broken because Optionable did not disclose certain alleged criminal acts in their SEC filings, even though the acts had not yet been alleged when the documents were filed. Several Defense lawyers jumped up simultaneously, outraged, to respond while Pollack was talking.
Judge Daniels told both Gottlieb/Nordlicht and Gelber/Cassidy to submit documents to him as to why CMEG’s request for a Summary Judgment is premature – otherwise he expects them to file an answer by January 18th. The problem here is that CMEG wants their motion answered BEFORE Cassidy is deposed.
And Then: BMO
Anne Beaumont's update covered 1) Pleadings 2) Discovery and 3) Document Production. Beaumont said that document production should be done by the end of February. She suggested that Cassidy’s deposition should happen after document production is completed. [personal note: document production seems to be putting a strain on BMO and it was not clear to me why this is the case, or what its relevance is going forward. I feel like I did not fully grasp parts of Beaumont's update]
Norton (for Optionable) asserted that he wants BMO trader David Lee deposed during this time as well. Beaumont clarified that she is not representing Lee and was not sure when Lee will be sentenced. Judge Daniels said that he would expect Lee’s deposition to happen within 30 to 60 days of Lee’s sentencing.
Regarding Joseph Saab of MF Global
Owen Pell wants Saab’s portion of the case stayed (halted) while MF Global’s bankruptcy is figured out. Pell is waiting to see if MF Global’s insurance will pay Saab’s legal fees, because if it doesn’t Saab may need to find another lawyer. Judge Daniels said that he will not halt this case himself, but he would honor such a request from the Judge handling the MF bankruptcy if such a request were made.
Next conference March 1, 2012
Plaintiffs Present: CFTC, Bank of Montreal, CMEG / NYMEX
Plaintiffs Absent: SEC
Defendants Represented: Optionable, Ed O’Connor, Mark Nordlicht, Kevin Cassidy and Joseph Saab
Plaintiffs:
CFTC: Eugene Smith
BMO: Anne Beaumont
CMEG: Daniel Pollack
Defense:
Nordlicht: Jason Gottlieb
Cassidy: Lawrence Gelber
O’Connor: Marni Rae Robin
Optionable: Michael Norton
Saab: Owen Pell
First Up: CFTC
Eugene Smith of the CFTC reported that the CFTC recently finalized a Consent Order with Optionable and O’Connor and that the CFTC expects to reach a similar outcome with Cassidy. Lawrence Gelber said that he needs to wait until after Cassidy is sentenced, before having further discussions with either the CFTC or the SEC. No one from the SEC attended the conference. Marni Rae Robin stated that O’Connor has not settled with the SEC.
Next Up: CMEG / NYMEX
Daniel Pollack said that CMEG filed a motion for Summary Judgment and anticipates an answer from Nordlicht and Cassidy by January 18th. Pollack's position is that when Nordlicht, Cassidy and O'Connor sold NYMEX a 19% stake in Optionable, a warantee was broken because Optionable did not disclose certain alleged criminal acts in their SEC filings, even though the acts had not yet been alleged when the documents were filed. Several Defense lawyers jumped up simultaneously, outraged, to respond while Pollack was talking.
Judge Daniels told both Gottlieb/Nordlicht and Gelber/Cassidy to submit documents to him as to why CMEG’s request for a Summary Judgment is premature – otherwise he expects them to file an answer by January 18th. The problem here is that CMEG wants their motion answered BEFORE Cassidy is deposed.
And Then: BMO
Anne Beaumont's update covered 1) Pleadings 2) Discovery and 3) Document Production. Beaumont said that document production should be done by the end of February. She suggested that Cassidy’s deposition should happen after document production is completed. [personal note: document production seems to be putting a strain on BMO and it was not clear to me why this is the case, or what its relevance is going forward. I feel like I did not fully grasp parts of Beaumont's update]
Norton (for Optionable) asserted that he wants BMO trader David Lee deposed during this time as well. Beaumont clarified that she is not representing Lee and was not sure when Lee will be sentenced. Judge Daniels said that he would expect Lee’s deposition to happen within 30 to 60 days of Lee’s sentencing.
Regarding Joseph Saab of MF Global
Owen Pell wants Saab’s portion of the case stayed (halted) while MF Global’s bankruptcy is figured out. Pell is waiting to see if MF Global’s insurance will pay Saab’s legal fees, because if it doesn’t Saab may need to find another lawyer. Judge Daniels said that he will not halt this case himself, but he would honor such a request from the Judge handling the MF bankruptcy if such a request were made.
Next conference March 1, 2012
Plaintiffs Present: CFTC, Bank of Montreal, CMEG / NYMEX
Plaintiffs Absent: SEC
Defendants Represented: Optionable, Ed O’Connor, Mark Nordlicht, Kevin Cassidy and Joseph Saab
Plaintiffs:
CFTC: Eugene Smith
BMO: Anne Beaumont
CMEG: Daniel Pollack
Defense:
Nordlicht: Jason Gottlieb
Cassidy: Lawrence Gelber
O’Connor: Marni Rae Robin
Optionable: Michael Norton
Saab: Owen Pell
No comments:
Post a Comment